Our Menu
Appetizers
$11.95
Shrimp in Beer Batter
Accompanied with a fruit sauce.
$11.95
$12.50
Escargot Chablisene
6 snails baked with fresh herbs in an aromatic garlic butter.
$12.50
$12.95
Old Mill Shrimp Cocktail
Served with cocktail sauce and lemon.
$12.95
$11.95
Crunchy Coconut Shrimp
With creamy pineapple coconut sauce.
$11.95
$11.50
Alaskan Mushroom Caps
Topped with crabmeat and Dejohn butter.
$11.50
$7.50
Toasted Raviolis
Cheese filled and served with marinara sauce for dipping.
$7.50
$6.75
French Onion Soup Au Gratin
$6.75
$4.75
Soup Du Jour
$4.75
Specialty Salads
Homemade dressings: House Italian, Bleu Cheese, Ranch, Peppercorn Parmesan, Russian, Honey Mustard, Poppyseed, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Fat Free Italian.
$11.00
Classic Caesar Salad
Crunchy Romaine tossed with our own Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese and croutons.
$11.00
$11.00
Wedge Salad
A wedge of crispy iceberg topped with Bleu cheese dressing, crumbled bleu cheese, bacon, and tomato.
$11.00
$11.50
Strawberry Salad
Assorted greens with fresh strawberries, glazed pecans, and crumbled bleu cheese. Served with poppy seed dressing.
$11.50
$11.75
Roasted Beet Salad
Maple horseradish glazed beets over mixed greens. Topped with pistachios, grapes, and goat cheese. Served with maple vinaigrette
$11.75
Entrées are served with hot rolls, relish tray, soup or House salad, starch, and vegetable. You may substitute French onion soup for soup du jour or salad for 4.25.
Old Mill Specialties
Specialties of the house and our three most popular dishes since 1946
$23.95
Chicken Old Mill
A casserole of boneless breast of chicken and broccoli florets topped with a rich Mornay sauce and parmesan cheese.
$23.95
$26.50
Shrimp Old Mill
A casserole of large shrimp over wild rice and topped with a rich Mornay sauce and parmesan cheese.
$26.50
$27.50
Braised Beef
Beef brisket seasoned and slow cooked for 8 hours until fork tender. Topped with a richly flavored sauce from it’s own juices.
$27.50
Favorites
$19.95
Broiled Marinated Chicken Breast
Served with Hollandaise sauce.
$19.95
$19.50
Broiled Ham Steak
Served with maple pineapple sauce.
$19.50
$19.95
Vegetables Old Mill
Fresh broccoli florets, sauteed mushrooms, and wild rice topped with our rich mornay sauce and parmesan cheese
$19.95
$16.95
Pasta Marinara
Angel hair pasta topped with a fresh tomato marinara sauce.
$16.95
$19.95
Vegetable Croquettes
Wild & brown rice combined with a blend of vegetables, breaded and topped with a creamy mushroom sauce.
$19.95
Served Sunday Only
$19.95
Boneless Chicken and Biscuits
$19.95
$25.95
Roast Turkey
All white meat served with Home Style Dressing and topped with turkey gravy.
$25.95
Seafood
$25.75
Crunchy Coconut Shrimp
With creamy pineapple coconut sauce.
$25.75
$26.95
Shrimp Sampler
A combination of favorites, coconut shrimp, fried shrimp, and shrimp in beer batter.
$26.95
$25.75
Shrimp in Beer Batter
Accompanied with a pungent fruit sauce and cocktail sauce.
$25.75
$23.50
Broiled Haddock with Butter Crumb Topping -Or- Crispy Fried Haddock
Hand breaded and served with tartar sauce.
$23.50
$33.00
Broiled Scallops
Served in lemon butter.
$33.00
$33.00
Fried Scallops
Fresh sea scallops hand breaded and served with tartar sauce.
$33.00
From the Broiler
$39.95
Broiled Filet Mignon Steak
Topped with fresh sautéed mushrooms.
$39.95
$34.95
New York Strip Steak
13 oz. steak topped with garlic herb butter.
$34.95
$40.75
Tournedos of Beef Tenderloin
One half topped with Bernaise sauce, the other a sauce of mushrooms, wine, and cream
$40.75
Slow roasted beef serve Au Jus. Market Price (petite or regular cut)
Roast Prime Ribs of Beef
(Saturday & Sunday Only)
Slow roasted beef serve Au Jus. Market Price (petite or regular cut)
Sides
$4.95
Fresh Sautéed Mushrooms
$4.95
$4.95
Steamed Wild Rice
$4.95
Petite Entrees
Featuring slightly smaller portions.
Available Thursday, Friday & Saturday.
$21.50
Chicken Old Mill
A casserole of boneless breast of chicken and broccoli florets topped with a rich Mornay sauce and parmesan cheese.
$21.50
$22.95
Shrimp Old Mill
A casserole of large shrimp over wild rice and topped with a rich Mornay sauce and parmesan cheese.
$22.95
$17.50
Smokey Bacon Cheeseburger
An 8 oz burger made from 90% lean ground sirloin topped with NY cheddar cheese and smokey bacon.
$17.50
$17.50
Broiled Marinated Chicken Breast
Served with Hollandaise sauce.
$17.50
$18.50
Chicken Tenders
Our own lightly breaded and seasoned tenders served with honey-mustard, BBQ, or marinara sauce.
$18.50
$23.75
Shrimp in Beer Batter
Served with a pungent fruit sauce and cocktail sauce for dipping.
$23.75
$23.75
Crunchy Coconut Shrimp
With creamy pineapple coconut sauce.
$23.75
Dinner Salads
$19.95
Chicken Caesar Salad
Our classic Caesar salad topped with grilled marinated chicken.
$19.95
$14.95
House Tossed Salad
$14.95
$15.95
Strawberry Salad
Assorted greens with fresh strawberries, glazed pecans, and crumbled bleu cheese. Served with poppy seed dressing.
$15.95
$14.95
Classic Caesar Salad
Crunchy Romaine tossed with our own Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese and croutons
$14.95
$15.95
Roasted Beet Salad
Maple horseradish glazed beets over mixed greens. Topped with pistachios, grapes, and goat cheese. Served with maple vinaigrette.
$15.95
$14.95
Wedge Salad
A wedge of crispy iceberg topped with Bleu cheese dressing, crumbled bleu cheese, bacon, and tomato.
$14.95
Soup, Salad, and More
Choose your favorite Dinner Salad and combine it with soup du jour or French Onion for an additional 4.50 - or - Create your own combination of appetizer, soup or salad.
Wine by the Glass
Barefoot - Merlot
Red
Lindeman’s -Shiraz
Barefoot - Merlot
Cabernet Sauvignon,
Pinot Noir
Cella - Lambrusco
Blush
Barefoot - White Zinfandel
Barefoot - Chardonnay
White
Barefoot-Pinot Grigio
Barefoot - Chardonnay
Barefoot-Riesling
Paul Masson - Chablis
Canei
Barefoot - Moscato
Old Mill Martinis
Pomegranate Martini
Pomegranate vodka with Triple Sec, and pomegranate juice.
Mocha Martini
Made with vodka, creme de cacao, and kahlúa.
Blue Martini
Vodka infused with fresh blueberries, raspberry liqueur, and a twist of lime.
Apple Martini
Absolut Citroen vodka, Apple Schnapps and lime juice.
Hazelnut Martini
Stolichnaya vanilla vodka and Frangelico liqueur.
lime juice.
Cosmopolitan
A blend of vodka, cranberry juice, triple sec and
lime juice.
On The Lite Side
Lower in alcohol but full of flavor.
Sweet Peach Tea
Iced tea with Peach Schnapps.
Coral Cooler
Blackberry and strawberry liqueur blended with orange juice, pineapple juice, and club soda.
Melon-Up
Midori melon liqueur and 7-Up.
Cranberry Spritz
Light Canadian whisky, cranberry juice, and club soda.
Georgia Peach
Peach Schnapps, Amaretto, and orange juice.
Tropical Lemonade
Bacardi Orange and Limon Rum, lemonade and lime juice.
Beer
Samuel Adams
Available Bottles
Blue Moon Belgian White
Samuel Adams
Yuengling
Coors Light
Michelob Ultra
Budweiser
Bud Light
Heineken (imported)
Non-Alcoholic Beverages
Fresh Watermelon Lemonade
Fresh Homemade Blueberry Lemonade
Soda
Sprite, Cola, Diet Cola, Ginger Ale, Tonic, Club Soda
Other Bottled Beverages
Saranac Root Beer, Saranac Orange Cream, Perrier Sparkling Mineral Water
Desserts
Any dessert served a la mode is $1.00 extra.
All Desserts are made from scratch & topped with real
whipped cream.
Any dessert served a la mode is $1.00 extra.
$6.95
Chocolate Truffle Torte with Raspberry Sauce
Very dark, very rich, and intensely chocolate.
$6.95
$7.50
NY Style Cheesecake
Add strawberries for an extra 50 cents.
$7.50
$6.95
Swiss Apple Fritters
Tender apple slices deep fried in batter, sprinkled with cinnamon and sugar and served on a vanilla cream and sliced almonds.
$6.95
$6.95
Turtle Pie
Coffee ice cream and Kahlua in a cookie and coconut crust, topped with hot fudge, butterscotch, whipped cream and sliced almonds.
$6.95
$6.95
Hot Butterscotch Ice Cream Cake
A slice of pound cake topped with vanilla ice cream, hot butterscotch, almonds and whipped cream.
$6.95
$6.95
Devils Food Hot Fudge Ice Cream Cake
$6.95
$5.95
Old Mill Walnut Pie
$5.95
$5.95
Key Lime Pie
$5.95
$5.95
Peanut Butter Pie
Creamy peanut butter filling in a chocolate cookie crust drizzled with peanut butter sauce.
$5.95
$5.95
Sundaes
Hot Fudge, Hot Butterscotch, Strawberry
$5.95
$4.95
Vanilla, Chocolate, Sherbet, or Sugar Free Ice Cream
$4.95
Parfaits
Creamy fresh ice cream topped with the liqueur of your choice.
$8.75
Cherry Jubilee
Cherry Heering and dark sweet cherries
$8.75
$8.75
Raspberry
Chambord liqueur and raspberries
$8.75
$7.95
Almond Delight
Amaretto and silvered almonds
$7.95
$7.95
Crème de Menthe
Crème de Menthe liqueur
$7.95
$7.95
Coffee
Coffee ice cream and kahlua
$7.95
International Coffees
$7.50
Irish Coffee
Bushmills whiskey with whipped cream
$7.50
$7.50
Mexican Coffee
Kahlua, topped with whipped cream
$7.50
$7.50
French Coffee
Grand Marnier, topped with whipped cream
$7.50
$7.50
Italian Coffee
Tuaca (Italian Brandy) with whipped cream
$7.50
$7.50
Jamaican Coffee
Tia Maria, Myers Rum, Dark Crème de Cacao
$7.50
$7.50
Nuts & Berries
Chambord liqueur and Frangelico
$7.50
Kid's Menu
Served with dinners are hot rolls, relish tray, salad or applesauce, vegetable, and your choice of baked potato, French fries or rice pilaf. Most of our regular menu items are also available in child sized portions.
$7.95
Chicken Fingers
Served with barbeque, ranch or honey mustard sauce.
$7.95
$5.95
Hot Dog
$5.95
$5.95
Corn Dog
$5.95
$7.50
Hamburger or Cheeseburger
$7.50
$6.50
Fish Fingers
$6.50